How to Choose the Best Dog Leash and Collar for Your Pet

When it comes to walking your dog, the leash and collar you choose play a major role in comfort, control, and safety. While it might seem like all dog leashes are the same, selecting the right one can make a huge difference in your dog’s behavior, not to mention the success of your walk. There is no "one size fits all option for dogs; the best choice depends on your dog’s size, breed, training level, and activity level. Understanding these guidelines helps make every dog walk a positive experience for both you and your best bud.

Basic Leash and Collar Options

There are many types of dog leashes and collars available, each designed for different dogs and walking styles. A traditional leash and flat collar combination works well for calm, obedient dogs that walk without pulling, as long as the collar fits snugly. It should be tight enough to stay secure but not so tight that it restricts breathing. 

For dogs that tend to slip out of their collars or are still learning leash manners, a slip leash or martingale leash can provide more control. These options tighten slightly when tension is applied, preventing escape and helping with training and leash correction. Breeds with narrow heads, such as Greyhounds or Whippets, particularly benefit from this type of leash.

For dogs with respiratory sensitivities or tracheal issues, a full-body harness or body leash is often a better choice. Harnesses distribute pressure evenly across the body instead of concentrating it on the neck, making them ideal for small breeds and brachycephalic dogs like Pugs and Boston Terriers. However, harnesses can allow dogs to pull more comfortably, which might not be suitable for strong or untrained dogs. In such cases, a Gentle Leader or head halter can provide additional control by guiding the dog’s head and discouraging pulling during training.

Other leash styles can be matched to your activities and lifestyle. Retractable dog leashes offer freedom of movement for well-trained dogs, while adjustable leashes allow you to change the length based on the walking environment. A double leash is perfect for pet owners walking two dogs at once, and a hands-free leash, worn around the waist, is ideal for runners, hikers, and active pet parents. For off-leash training or for exploring open spaces safely, a long-line leash gives your dog extra range without losing control. 

With so many options available, finding the best dog leash for your pet begins with understanding their needs and your walking routine.

Matching the Leash to the Dog

By Size and Strength

Your dog’s size and strength determine how durable and supportive their leash should be. Small and toy breeds benefit from lightweight nylon or leather leashes that won’t weigh them down. Large or powerful dogs require thicker, wider, and stronger materials with a padded handle to prevent injuries like leash burn.

By Breed

Some breeds benefit from specialized dog harness or leash types:

• Flat-faced breeds (Pugs, French Bulldogs, Boston Terriers): Use body leashes for dogs with respiratory sensitivities. A full-body harness prevents pressure on the neck.
• Hounds and sighthounds (Greyhounds, Whippets): These breeds can slip out of standard collars easily, so martingale collars are safest.
• Strong pulling breeds (Labradors, Huskies, Boxers): A front-clip harness or head halter offers better control and reduces pulling behavior.
• Small breeds (Yorkshire Terriers, Chihuahuas): Lightweight harnesses are more comfortable and prevent throat injury from collars.
• Working and athletic breeds (Border Collies, German Shepherds): Adjustable or hands-free leashes pair well with active lifestyles and dog training routines.

By Age and Training Level

• Puppies: Start with a short 4- to 6-foot nylon leash and a flat collar or lightweight harness. Avoid retractable leashes during puppy training, as they can reinforce pulling!
• Adolescents and Young Adults: Dogs in training may benefit from martingale collars, head halters, or no-pull harnesses to maintain control and reinforce good walking habits.
• Adult and Senior Dogs: Older dogs often do well with standard or adjustable leashes that allow slower, more controlled dog walks. Harnesses help support aging joints and prevent pressure on the neck.

Choosing Between Collars and Harnesses

Collars: Ideal for dogs who walk calmly and are leash trained. Puppies can start with flat collars for short walks, while experienced walkers benefit from lightweight options for everyday use. However, collars are not suitable for dogs prone to pulling or breeds with narrow heads that may slip free.

Harnesses: Best for dogs that pull, have neck sensitivities, or require additional support. A body leash for dogs with a front-clip design helps redirect movement, making walks safer and more controlled. Harnesses are particularly beneficial for small dogs, older dogs, or breeds susceptible to tracheal issues.

Handler Comfort, Safety, and Care

Choosing the best dog leash isn’t just about your dog’s needs - it’s also about your comfort and control during every dog walk. Materials and grip design can make a big difference, especially for longer walks or active dogs. Leather leashes are soft, durable, and provide a natural grip that improves with age, while padded nylon or neoprene handles help prevent hand fatigue and offer a secure hold. Reflective or lighted leashes are excellent choices for nighttime walks, improving visibility and safety for both you and your dog. Always inspect leashes for signs of wear and replace them if you notice fraying, stiffness, or weakened stitching.

Proper leash care helps extend its life and keeps walks sanitary. Most nylon leashes can be hand-washed using warm water and mild dog shampoo, then thoroughly rinsed and air-dried. Leather leashes require a gentler touch. It's best to wipe them clean with a damp cloth and occasionally apply a pet-safe leather conditioner to maintain flexibility and prevent cracking. Regular cleaning prevents odor and bacteria buildup, keeping your leash strong, comfortable, and safe for daily use.

Benefits of Using the Right Leash

Beyond safety, a properly fitted leash and collar or harness help reinforce training, prevent injuries, and create a more enjoyable walking experience. Regular dog walks support physical health, reduce behavioral problems, and strengthen the bond between you and your pet. For handlers, leash walking promotes exercise, mindfulness, and community engagement.

When to Seek Veterinary Guidance

While choosing a leash or harness may seem simple, your veterinarian can help you decide what’s safest and most effective for your dog’s health and behavior. Some dogs have medical or orthopedic conditions that make certain collars or harnesses unsafe. Others may need specialized recommendations to support dog training or manage pulling habits safely.

Before introducing a new leash or collar, talk to your veterinarian about your dog’s breed, size, and activity level. They can help you find the right fit, and help every walk be comfotable and controlled.

Don't have a vet in your area yet? We can help you find a local veterinarian.